Here is a closer look at the 2 boxes this month:
You can check out the full post on my September Ipsy Bag here
The value of this month's Ipsy bag was pretty on par with what each month comes with; but the contents were just meh for me. I like the the exfoliator and serum, the lip injection is just okay, but I'm not thrilled with the blush or nail polish. Certainly not my favorite month.
This month's Topbox value was pretty normal with each month, although usually at least one item is full sized - but not this month. Some of the samples were a little small, but I will use everything that came this month. In addition the these items, Topbox also sent all there subscribers an additional box with 9 more samples in it!
I have to say that Topbox wins this month - I will use all the samples, plush they gave each subscriber an amazing add on!
Also, if you are interested, you can check out my past box comparisons here for a look at how the past bags have stacked up!