Wednesday, October 8, 2014

September 2014 Beauty Box Comparison - Ipsy vs. Topbox vs. Beauty Box 5

Here is a chart comparing the September 2014 Beauty Boxes:



Ipsy ~ Ipsy had a good value; however, overall I wasn't thrilled with the products I received. The lip-gloss formula was great but the color wasn't and the moisturizer is not for my skin type. I will use 3 of the products so it wasn't all a miss, just Ipsy can do better!

You can check out my other reviews here, and if you are interested in signing up for Ipsy, I would love it if you used my referral link here: http://www.ipsy.com/r/b8nk?sid=ipsypoints&cid=general

Beauty Box 5 ~ Beauty Box 5 was slightly disappointing this month. The shipping was very slow and the product value was slightly lacking for me. 1 of the products had $0 value, 1 was a set of toe separators, and 1 was a no name nail polish. I will use all 5 items I received, just in terms of products selection I feel like they could do a bit better. Not my favorite box.

You can check out my other Beauty Box 5 reviews here, and if you are interested in signing up for Beauty Box 5 I would love it if you used my referral code here: http://www.beautybox5.com/?u=10450

TopBox ~ Topbox had a great value this month and a good selection of skin care, nails and hair products. I will use all the products I received - my only comment is that I would like to see a little bit more makeup products from TopBox. Overall, Topbox was my favorite of all 3 inexpensive beauty boxes that ship to Canada this month!

You can check out my other Topbox reviews here 

I like the idea of comparing these 3 boxes - I think it can be helpful for mew people looking for a box to sign up for. I think everyone wants to make sure they get products they like with a good value. For me, I like to make sure that I carry on with subscriptions that I am happy with! 1 month is often not enough to select a box to try, so check out my past months box comparison posts here!

What was your favorite box for September?

3 comments :

  1. Great comparison. Looks like TopBox is the best

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've heard Topbox is good. I wish we could get it in the US!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I feel that way about so many boxes in the U.S. - there is so many more there than in Canada!!! I do really like it - maybe one day they will expand!

      Delete